I have never had a bad experience at the Brotherhood. I've enjoyed my food....especially their mediterrean pizza or the philly cheese steak eggrolls. I've had tasty mixed drinks there too. I do agree that the prices can be high for some items. Overall good atmosphere. I love the outdoor patio and bar in the summer!
Presentation
Food
Service
Ambiance
Value
not the place to go! September 09, 2008 Reviewer: Brantpoint
Do not be deceived by the looks, especially the patio. This is not the place you want to go. The food is horrible and quite expensive considering they are so bad. That goes for their mixed drinks too. Don’t bother, that’s my advice. There are better places in Nantucket.
Used to be there was a long line outside the Brotherhood. It had few tables, and lots of mystique. Now it has no lines, lots of seats, and no mystique. And no magic.